Here’s the question nobody asks early enough: "Can I actually insure this house, and what will it cost?" In Southwest Florida, that answer can change your monthly payment more than the interest rate does. It can even change whether the deal closes. So let’s talk about how to shop for homeowners insurance the right way, before you’re out of time.
The short answer
Start getting quotes the day your offer is accepted, not the week before closing. Get a 4-point inspection if the home is older, and a wind mitigation inspection on almost anything. Know the roof’s age, from a permit or a receipt. Use an independent insurance agent who can quote several companies, and ask whether Citizens is even an option for you. Compare the hurricane deductible, not just the premium. Then bind the policy well before closing. Citizens won’t bind new coverage while a tropical storm or hurricane watch or warning is up anywhere in Florida, and other companies set their own storm rules.
Start the clock on day one
Your insurance quote belongs inside your inspection period, not after it. On the Florida Realtors/Florida Bar "AS IS" contract, a blank inspection period means 15 days, and weekends count. That’s your cleanest window to walk away if the house turns out to be hard or expensive to insure. (Our guide to what a buyer’s agent does during Florida inspections covers that period in detail.)
Here’s what I would do. Call an insurance agent while you’re still writing the offer. Ask what they’ll need to quote the house, then order those inspections the same day you schedule your home inspection.
What the insurance company will want to know
Every company has its own underwriting rules, so the list varies. These come up constantly in Southwest Florida:
- Roof age and type. The date the roof was fully replaced matters, and so does whether it’s shingle, tile or metal. Ask the seller for the roof permit or invoice, and check the city or county permit records.
- A 4-point inspection. A licensed inspector reports on the roof, electrical, plumbing and heating and cooling. It’s an insurance company requirement, not a state law, and companies set their own age cutoffs.
- A wind mitigation inspection. This form documents roof shape, roof-to-wall connections and opening protection. Florida law requires insurers’ rate filings to include discounts, credits or other adjustments for qualifying wind-loss mitigation features, which is why this inspection can pay for itself. We covered the form itself in the inspections guide, so I won’t repeat it here.
- Flood zone and elevation. Flood is a separate policy. If you haven’t priced it yet, start with our guide on whether you need flood insurance in Southwest Florida.
- The seller’s claims history. Ask your agent whether the home’s prior claims will affect your quote, and ask the seller what was claimed and repaired.
One more thing. A 4-point or roof report that shows active leaks, exposed wiring or other hazards can stop a quote cold. Better to learn that during your inspection period than after.
What Florida law says about roof age
Real talk about the "they won’t insure a roof over 15 years old" rumor. It’s partly true and partly not. Here’s what the law actually says, as of November 17, 2026.
Under Florida Statutes section 627.7011(5), an insurer can’t refuse to issue or renew a homeowner’s policy solely because the roof is less than 15 years old. If the roof is 15 years or older, the insurer has to let you get a roof inspection by an authorized inspector, at your expense, before requiring a replacement. And if that inspection shows at least five years of useful life left, the insurer can’t refuse to write or renew solely because of roof age.
What that law doesn’t do is make the roof’s condition irrelevant. An older roof can still affect your price and your options. And the law doesn’t apply to mobile home policies. So get the roof date early, and if it’s older, get the roof inspected inside your inspection period.
Where Citizens fits
Citizens Property Insurance Corporation is Florida’s state-created insurer. It isn’t a backup plan you get to choose freely. Florida law sets who’s eligible.
- The 20% rule. For a primary home, if a private company authorized in Florida offers you comparable coverage, you’re not eligible for a new Citizens policy unless that offer is more than 20% higher than the Citizens premium. A similar 20% test applies to homes that aren’t your primary residence.
- The clearinghouse. Citizens runs every new personal policy application through its clearinghouse first, to see if a private company will make an offer. Your agent does this part, but you should know why you might get steered to another company.
- Citizens inspections. As of November 17, 2026, Citizens’ published underwriting pages say it requires a 4-point inspection for homeowner applications on homes more than 20 years old, done within the past year by a Florida-licensed inspector. Shingle roofs over 25 years old and tile, slate, clay, concrete or metal roofs over 50 years old need documentation of at least five years of remaining life, or proof of a full replacement.
- Flood is coming. Citizens is phasing in a flood insurance requirement. Our flood insurance guide has the dates, so plan for both policies if Citizens is your likely carrier.
Read the deductibles before the premium
A cheap premium with a big hurricane deductible isn’t cheap. It just moves the cost to the worst week of your year.
Florida Statutes section 627.701 says that before issuing a homeowner’s policy, an insurer must offer hurricane deductible options of $500, 2%, 5% and 10% of the dwelling limit (unless the percentage works out to less than $500). Do the math in dollars. On a $400,000 dwelling limit, 2% is $8,000 and 10% is $40,000.
A few other things worth knowing:
- It’s a calendar-year deductible. The hurricane deductible applies once per calendar year to covered hurricane losses with the same insurer or insurer group. If a second hurricane hits in the same year, the insurer can apply the greater of whatever is left of your hurricane deductible or your regular (other perils) deductible.
- Ask about a separate roof deductible. Florida law lets insurers add a roof deductible of up to 2% of the dwelling limit or 50% of the roof replacement cost, whichever is less. It doesn’t apply to hurricane roof losses or a few other situations, and the insurer has to give you a premium credit for it. At issuance, you can reject it in writing.
- Keep deductible money in savings. Our home cost guide shows how to budget for it alongside HOA and district fees.
Coverage questions that matter more than the price
When you compare quotes, make sure you’re comparing the same thing. Ask each agent:
- Is the dwelling limit based on what it would cost to rebuild, not what I’m paying for the house?
- Are losses settled at replacement cost or actual cash value?
- How much law and ordinance coverage is included? It helps pay to bring a repair up to current code. Florida law requires insurers to offer it, and the amount can be limited to 25% or 50% of the dwelling limit, which you choose.
- What’s the hurricane deductible in dollars, and is there a separate roof deductible?
- Are screen enclosures, pool cages, fences and detached structures covered, and for how much?
- What discounts did you apply from the wind mitigation report, and is anything missing?
- Does this policy cover flood? (Standard homeowners policies generally don’t, so plan on a separate flood policy.)
These are the questions to take to a licensed insurance agent. I can help you get organized, but your agent and your policy are what decide your coverage.
Protect yourself in the contract
Insurance isn’t automatically a way out of a Florida contract. The protection comes from what you sign.
Your inspection period. On the "AS IS" form, you can cancel in your sole discretion during the inspection period. That includes because the insurance quote came back ugly. After that deadline passes, that option is gone.
Rider H. The Florida Realtors/Florida Bar Homeowner’s/Flood Insurance rider lets you set a maximum first-year premium, in dollars or as a percentage of the price. If you can’t get homeowner’s insurance (including windstorm) from a standard carrier or Citizens at or below that amount by the deadline, you can cancel and get your deposit back. If you leave the deadline blank, the rider uses the earlier of 30 days after the Effective Date or 10 days before closing. It’s optional, so it has to be added.
Cash buyers, this is for you too. No lender doesn’t mean no risk. Without that inspection-period exit or Rider H, an uninsurable or unaffordable house is still your house.
Contract language is a legal question. If you’re unsure what your contract allows, have a Florida real estate attorney review it before you sign.
Bind it before closing, and before a storm
"Bound" means the coverage is actually in force, not just quoted. Your lender will want proof of coverage before closing, and you want it too.
Hurricane season runs June 1 through November 30, and that matters for your closing date. Citizens’ rule is that agents can’t bind new coverage or increase coverage, regardless of the effective date, while a tropical storm or hurricane watch or warning is in effect for any part of Florida. Other companies set their own binding rules. If a storm shows up the week of your closing and you haven’t bound coverage, you may be stuck waiting.
After you’re insured, read the paperwork. Under Florida Statutes section 627.4133, an insurer can cancel a new homeowner policy during its first 60 days with at least 20 days’ written notice (or without that notice for a material misstatement or a failed underwriting requirement). After 60 days, cancellation is limited to specific reasons, and one of them is not meeting, within 60 days, underwriting requirements the company set before coverage started. So if your new carrier asks for a repair or a document, handle it fast.
Your insurance shopping checklist
- Call an independent insurance agent before or right when your offer is accepted.
- Get the roof’s date of last full replacement from a permit or invoice.
- Order a wind mitigation inspection, plus a 4-point and roof inspection if the age of the home or roof calls for it.
- Get flood quotes at the same time, even if the lender won’t require flood.
- Compare at least two or three quotes on the same dwelling limit, settlement type and deductibles.
- Ask whether Citizens is an option and why or why not.
- Decide inside your inspection period, or use Rider H for more time.
- Bind coverage early and send proof to your lender and closing agent.
- Respond quickly to any request from the new insurer after closing.
Florida’s Office of Insurance Regulation has a free CHOICES tool with sample average rates by county, and you can confirm a company is licensed in Florida through the state’s company search. If you get stuck, the Florida Department of Financial Services has a consumer helpline at 1-877-693-5236.
Common questions
When should I start shopping for homeowners insurance on a Florida home?
As soon as your offer is accepted, or even while you’re writing it. Your quote should come back inside your inspection period, because that’s usually your cleanest chance to cancel if the house is hard or expensive to insure. On the Florida Realtors/Florida Bar “AS IS” contract, a blank inspection period is 15 days, and weekends count.
Can an insurer refuse my policy because of the roof’s age?
Not solely because of age if the roof is less than 15 years old, under Florida Statutes section 627.7011(5). For a roof 15 years or older, the insurer has to let you get an inspection by an authorized inspector before requiring a replacement, and it can’t refuse solely because of age if the inspection shows at least five years of useful life left. The roof’s condition can still affect your price and options.
Can I just get a Citizens policy?
Only if you’re eligible. For a primary home, you can’t get a new Citizens policy if an authorized private insurer offers comparable coverage at a premium that is not more than 20% higher than Citizens’ premium. New applications go through the Citizens clearinghouse first.
What is a hurricane deductible in Florida?
It’s the amount you pay on a covered hurricane loss before the policy pays. Before issuing a homeowner’s policy, Florida insurers must offer hurricane deductible options of $500, 2%, 5% and 10% of the dwelling limit. It applies on a calendar-year basis. Do the math in dollars before you choose.
Is insurance a contingency in a Florida purchase contract?
Not automatically. On the “AS IS” form, your inspection period lets you cancel in your sole discretion. The optional Rider H lets you set a maximum first-year premium and cancel if you can’t get homeowner’s or flood coverage at or below it by the deadline. Have a Florida real estate attorney review your contract if you’re unsure.
Why does my agent want insurance bound before closing?
Your lender needs proof of coverage, and storms can freeze new policies. Citizens won’t bind new or increased coverage while a tropical storm or hurricane watch or warning is in effect for any part of Florida, and other companies set their own rules.
SERHANT.
Heidi Choiniere, REALTOR®
FL License #SL3445168
The Salty Palm Group
(941) 876-3990 · [email protected]
Related guides from the journal
Sources
Checked November 17, 2026. Laws, underwriting rules and forms change. This is general information, not insurance or legal advice. Confirm details with a licensed Florida insurance agent and, for contract questions, a Florida real estate attorney.
- Florida Statutes: Section 627.7011 (2026), homeowners’ policies: replacement cost and law and ordinance offers (1), roof age rules (5).
- Florida Statutes: Section 627.701 (2026), hurricane deductible offers (3), calendar-year application (5), separate roof deductible (10).
- Florida Statutes: Section 627.351(6)(c)5. (2026), Citizens eligibility and the 20% rule.
- Florida Statutes: Section 627.3518 (2026), Citizens policyholder eligibility clearinghouse program.
- Florida Statutes: Section 627.4133 (2026), notice of cancellation and nonrenewal.
- Florida Statutes: Section 627.0629 (2026), rate filings must include windstorm mitigation discounts and credits.
- Citizens Property Insurance Corporation: Inspections (four-point and older-roof requirements).
- Citizens Property Insurance Corporation: When is a four-point inspection needed? (updated February 18, 2026) and roof age requirements (updated March 17, 2026).
- Citizens Property Insurance Corporation: Clearinghouse (eligibility and the 20% test).
- Citizens Property Insurance Corporation: Hurricane or tropical storm binding suspension rule (updated December 30, 2025).
- Florida Office of Insurance Regulation: Wind Mitigation Resources (hurricane season dates, inspector authorization) and CHOICES rate comparison (sample average rates; illustrative only).
- Florida Department of Financial Services: Division of Consumer Services (helpline 1-877-693-5236) and Active Company Search.
- Florida Realtors: “Addendum H Adds Flood Insurance Peace of Mind” (July 28, 2026), Florida Realtors/Florida Bar Homeowner’s/Flood Insurance rider.
