You’ve seen the ads. A friendly voice on TV says they’ll buy your house for cash, as-is, no repairs, no showings, close when you want. Another one says you can sell now and keep living there. Some of those offers are legitimate businesses doing exactly what they say. The catch is the part the commercial doesn’t have time for: what it costs you. So here’s the fine print, read out loud.
The short answer
A cash offer buys you speed and convenience, and you pay for it out of your equity. As-is cash buyers price your house around what they can resell it for after repairs, minus the repairs, their holding costs and their profit. “Sell now, stay later” deals usually turn you into a renter in the house you used to own. Neither is automatically a scam, and either can be the right call. But never sign one until you’ve seen a real side-by-side number for listing the same house.
How cash buyers decide what to offer you
Investors who buy homes to fix and resell work backward from the after-repair value, or ARV: what the house should sell for once it’s fixed up. A rule of thumb that gets quoted constantly is the “70% rule.” HomeVestors, the franchise company behind “We Buy Ugly Houses,” describes it on its own franchise blog as an industry-accepted guide for flippers: don’t pay more than 70% of the after-repair value to buy a home you plan to flip. Notice that’s 70% of the fixed-up price, before anyone subtracts the cost of the new roof.
To be fair, HomeVestors doesn’t publish a formula for sellers, and its franchises are independently owned. Its consumer FAQ says an offer considers your home’s condition, the cost and time of repairs, nearby comparable values, any real estate commission that might come into play, and holding costs like taxes, insurance, utilities and HOA dues while the work gets done. That’s an honest list. Every line on it comes out of your price.
Online cash buyers, often called iBuyers, work a little differently. Opendoor charges a service charge on top of its offer and says its average typically falls between 5% and 8%, can be lower or higher depending on the home and market, and is never higher than 14%. Its help center says the exact charge shows up in your offer breakdown. So read the breakdown, not just the headline number.
Then there are wholesalers. A wholesaler puts your house under contract, then sells that contract to another investor for a fee. You may never meet the person who actually buys your home. AARP has warned that a contract can get passed from wholesaler to wholesaler, and if nobody bites, the closing may not happen at all.
What “sell now, stay in your home” actually means
These programs go by friendly names, but the structure is usually a sale-leaseback. You sell the house to a company, sign a lease, and pay rent to live in what used to be your home. Some include an option to buy it back later.
The Federal Trade Commission put out a consumer alert in October 2024 calling these deals “far from risk-free.” Its words: once you sell, you’re a renter, and the risks “often hidden in the fine print of complicated contracts” include “hefty fees, exorbitant rent, and even eviction” if the rent goes up and you can’t pay it.
This isn’t theoretical. NPR investigated sale-leaseback company EasyKnock in 2024. After reviewing court records from more than a dozen transactions where residents sued, NPR found the deals cost some people tens of thousands of dollars in equity and that most people didn’t buy their homes back. EasyKnock denied wrongdoing, then shut down in December 2024. In June 2026, Michigan’s Attorney General announced an agreement resolving its investigation. The office had alleged that homeowners were told they’d receive 100% of their home’s value but got only a fraction in cash after processing fees, closing costs and repair holdbacks, while rent and the repurchase price climbed every year. The agreement created an $85,000 fund for affected customers and bars the companies involved from doing sale-leasebacks in Michigan.
Before you sign one of these, get answers in writing. What’s the actual cash at closing after every fee and holdback? What’s the rent now, and how much can it go up? How long is the lease? What’s the buyback price, and how would you realistically finance it? What happens to your equity if you can’t?
What Florida law says
Florida has a few protections that matter here.
- If you’re in foreclosure: Florida Statutes section 501.1377 covers “equity purchasers” who buy a home in foreclosure while the owner keeps a lease-back or buyback interest. It requires a written agreement with specific disclosures and gives the homeowner until 5 p.m. on the third business day after signing to cancel. If there’s a buyback right, a repurchase price more than 17% a year above what the buyer put in is presumed unconscionable, and a lease-option deal like this is presumed to be a loan, not a sale.
- If someone pays you cash for your listing rights: Florida went after MV Realty, which paid homeowners small upfront sums in exchange for 40-year exclusive listing agreements backed by liens. In December 2025, Attorney General James Uthmeier announced a final judgment requiring MV to remove liens from more than 9,000 Florida homes. Florida Statutes section 475.279 now says these kinds of long-term, paid listing agreements can’t create a lien on your home.
- Wholesaling: As of November 2026, I couldn’t find a Florida statute written specifically for wholesaling, though several other states have passed one. What Florida does have is its real estate license law. Under Chapter 475, someone who negotiates the sale of real property for another person, for pay, is acting as a broker, and doing that without a license is a third-degree felony. So if someone is marketing your house to other buyers for a fee and isn’t licensed, that’s worth a question.
When a cash offer makes sense
There are real reasons to take one, and I won’t pretend otherwise:
- The house needs more work than you can afford or want to manage, like a roof, plumbing, storm damage or a full gut job.
- You inherited a house in another state, or you’re handling an estate, and nobody wants to clean out, repair and show it from a thousand miles away.
- You need to be done by a specific date, and certainty matters more than the last dollar.
- The house has issues that make a buyer’s financing hard to get.
The honest tradeoff is simple: speed and certainty cost money. Sometimes that’s worth it. You just deserve to know the price before you pay it.
Cash offer vs. listing: an example
This is an example with made-up numbers, not real data and not a quote for your home. Say a three-bedroom house in North Port, Florida needs a new roof and has an original kitchen. If it were fixed up, it might sell for $400,000, and the repairs would cost about $40,000.
| Line item (example) | As-is cash offer | Listed as-is |
|---|---|---|
| How the price is set | $400,000 × 70% − $40,000 repairs (the rule of thumb) | What a buyer who plans to fix it might pay on the open market |
| Sale price | $240,000 | $340,000 |
| Commission and brokerage fees | $0 | −$17,000 (5% in this example; commissions are negotiable) |
| Florida deed doc stamps (70¢ per $100) | $0 (buyer covers closing costs in this example) | −$2,380 |
| Title, closing and other costs | $0 | −$3,000 |
| Carrying costs while it’s on the market | $0 | −$2,500 (about three months) |
| Estimated net before your mortgage payoff | $240,000 | $315,120 |
In this made-up example, the cash route nets about $75,000 less. In some situations, a roof that won’t pass insurance, a house full of 40 years of belongings, or a deadline you can’t move, that gap is worth paying. In others it’s a very expensive way to skip a few showings. Your numbers will be different, which is the whole point of running them.
Questions to ask before you sign
- Is there an assignment clause? Look for “and/or assigns” next to the buyer’s name. Ask directly: “Are you buying this house, or selling the contract?”
- How much is the earnest money, and when does it go hard? A token deposit with a long inspection window means the buyer can walk away and you’ve taken your home off the market for nothing.
- What can change the price after inspection? A common complaint is a strong offer to lock you in, then a “we found some issues” price cut right before closing. Ask how the number was built and what would change it.
- Who’s closing it? Use a licensed Florida title company or real estate attorney. Money flows from the buyer to you at closing, never the other way.
- What is my cash at closing? Get the net number in writing, after every fee, repair credit and holdback.
- Can I take this home and show someone? The FTC’s advice is blunt: if a buyer pressures you to act immediately, walk away. The CFPB lists pressure to act immediately and pushing you to sign papers you don’t understand among the signs of a foreclosure-relief scam, along with being asked to sign over the title to your home.
What I do
When someone tells me they’re thinking about a cash offer, I don’t talk them out of it. I give them two real numbers. One is the as-is cash route: what a cash buyer would realistically pay for the house today. The other is what the house would likely net if we listed it, as-is or with a few smart fixes. Then you pick. No pressure, no sales pitch, and no hard feelings if cash wins.
I’ve been part of nearly 400 closings, and the most expensive mistake I see isn’t picking the wrong option. It’s picking one without seeing the other. If you want the truth, Ask Heidi: (941) 876-3990 or [email protected].
Common questions
Do cash home buyers pay market value?
Usually not, and they don’t claim to. As-is buyers work backward from what the house will sell for after repairs, then subtract repairs, holding costs and profit. A common rule of thumb is no more than 70% of the after-repair value. Online buyers charge a service fee instead; Opendoor says its average is typically 5% to 8% and never above 14%.
What is a sale-leaseback, or “sell now, stay later”?
You sell your home to a company and rent it back. Some deals include an option to buy it back. The FTC warns the risks can include hefty fees, rising rent and eviction if you can’t pay. Get the cash at closing, the rent, rent increases and the buyback price in writing before you sign.
Is wholesaling legal in Florida?
As of November 2026, Florida has no statute written specifically for wholesaling. Florida’s real estate license law, Chapter 475, still applies: negotiating the sale of someone else’s property for pay without a license is a third-degree felony. Ask any cash buyer whether they will close themselves or assign your contract.
Can I cancel a cash offer after I sign?
It depends on the contract. Some buyers offer a short cancellation window; HomeVestors’ FAQ describes a 3-day grace period. If your home is in foreclosure and you keep a lease-back or buyback interest, Florida Statutes section 501.1377 gives you until 5 p.m. on the third business day after signing to cancel.
When does a cash offer make sense?
When the house needs major repairs, you’re handling an inherited home or estate from far away, you need a guaranteed date, or financing would be hard for a buyer to get. Compare it against a listed-sale estimate for the same house first.
SERHANT.
Heidi Choiniere, REALTOR®
FL License #SL3445168
The Salty Palm Group
(941) 876-3990 · [email protected]
Related guides from the journal
Sources
Checked November 19, 2026. This is general information, not legal or tax advice. Laws, company terms and fees change; have a Florida real estate attorney review any contract before you sign.
- HomeVestors: House Flipping Cost Calculator (the 70% rule) and We Buy Ugly Houses FAQ (offer factors, 3-day grace period, closing costs).
- Opendoor: Most common misconceptions about Opendoor (5–8% average, never above 14%) and What is Opendoor’s service charge?
- Federal Trade Commission: Risky business: offers to cash out your home equity through a “sale-leaseback” (Oct. 3, 2024; archived copy).
- Consumer Financial Protection Bureau: How to spot and avoid foreclosure relief scams.
- NPR: Sale-leaseback deals can cost homeowners thousands (June 18, 2024) and A company that turned homeowners into renters abruptly shuts down (Dec. 6, 2024).
- Michigan Department of Attorney General: AG Nessel Secures Agreement in Investigation of Sale-Leaseback Company (June 3, 2026).
- AARP: Beware of ‘Let Us Buy Your Home’ Ads.
- Florida Office of the Attorney General: Attorney General James Uthmeier Secures Judgment Against MV Realty.
- Florida Statutes (2026): Section 501.1377 (foreclosure-rescue transactions), Section 475.279 (residential loan alternative agreements), Section 475.01 and Section 475.42 (broker definition; unlicensed activity).
- Florida Department of Revenue: Documentary Stamp Tax (70 cents per $100 on deeds outside Miami-Dade).
